Welcome to IVF Authority - World Renowned Resource for IVF Information

Welcome to IVF Authority Blog

Search by Topic

    Search by Date

      << Back to IVF Page
    • The Needle vs. the Dish: Should ICSI Be Used in All IVF?

      Phone:
      702-892-9696

      Fax:
      702-892-9666

      The introduction of Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection or ICSI has made it possible to fertilize eggs with sperm derived from men with the severest degrees of male infertility. What’s more, pregnancy rates achieved by this method of fertilization are as high, if not higher, than those of conventional IVF performed in cases of non-male-factor infertility.

      ICSI involves the direct injection of a single sperm into each egg under direct microscopic vision and requires a high level of technical expertise.  In fact, even when there is an absence of sperm in the ejaculate such as occurs in cases of a) congenital absence of the Vas deferens (when a man is born without these major sperm collecting ducts), b) in cases where the vasa deferentia (ducts that carry the sperm from the testicles to the urethra for ejaculation) are obstructed (such as following vasectomy or trauma), and c) in some cases of testicular failure or where the man has impotence, ICSI can be performed with sperm obtained through Testicular Sperm Extraction (TESE), or aspiration (TESA). In such cases, the birth rate is usually no different than when IVF is performed for indications other than male infertility.

      When evaluating all available information regarding the use of ICSI…here is what  emerges:

      The performance of ICSI for male factor infertility is associated with:

      1. A slight increase in certain structural embryo chromosomal abnormalities (e.g.,  deletions).
      2. A slight increase in the incidence of miscarriages
      3. A slight increase in the incidence of birth defects
      4. An increased potential that male offspring will also present with male infertility later in life.

      However…

      When ICSI is performed for indications OTHER THAN male infertility there is:

      1. No increase in the risk of subsequent embryo chromosome deletions
      2. No increase in the incidence of miscarriages
      3. No increased incidence of birth defects
      4. No increased potential for a resulting male offspring to be infertile in later in life

      It follows that the complications  associated with ICSI are likely attributable to the indication for which ICSI is being done (the male factor infertility) rather than with the ICSI procedure itself.

      The observation  that ICSI, when performed for the treatment of male infertility increases the potential for  resulting male offspring to  be infertile  later in life,  suggests that ICSI allows sperm that carry DNA with male factor infertility characteristics to the egg at fertilization.

      Given the above, in my opinion, there is really no down side to performing ICSI on all patients undergoing IVF. There are a number of reasons why there is a strong movement afoot to perform ICSI across the board, regardless of whether there is proven sperm dysfunction.

      First, it is mandated for the treatment of all cases of male infertility, anyway. Second, as mentioned above, it is not the procedure of ICSI itself that causes complications, but rather the indication for which ICSI is done.

      Thus the performance of ICSI across the board should be an acceptable policy. Here are a few points that support this position:

      • IVF is associated with unanticipated absent or poor fertilization in 12-15% of cases. In fact, newer tests of sperm function such as the sperm chromatin structure assay (SCSA), have shown that DNA damage may be present in sperm derived from men with both normal and abnormal semen analyses. Undoubtedly, male infertility is present in such cases regardless of whether the semen analysis is “normal” or “abnormal”.  Forced fertilization of eggs using ICSI will help couples avoid the disappointment associated with unanticipated failed fertilization that might otherwise occur in such cases.
      • Fertilization in the Petri dish requires an interaction between sperm and the cumulus cells that surround the egg. During many IVF procedures, there is a need to remove the surrounding cumulus cells in order to examine its structure, its maturity and to prepare it for preimplantation genetic screening (PGS). Having removed the cumulus cells, the egg is far less capable of being fertilized spontaneously, thus mandating ICSI in such cases.
      • In all cases of infertility, whether of female, male or “unexplained” nature, regardless of sperm function, ICSI bypasses most dysfunctions, eliminating the majority of barriers to fertilization. If, in spite of ICSI, fertilization still does not occur, then there is a greater chance of the underlying cause being genetic/chromosomal (involving egg and/or sperm), making the argument for routine ICSI even more compelling.

      The proposition for “universal”, use of ICSI is based on a higher fertilization rate than by conventional IVF, the fact that male infertility is often “occult” (not revealed through traditional sperm analyses) , the need to perform ICSI when cryopreserved sperm is used in IVF, and the necessity to do ICSI in all cases of PGD/PGS. However, the most compelling justification might be the fact that the procedure of ICSI itself, apparently does no damage.

      Tags:

      6 Responses to “The Needle vs. the Dish: Should ICSI Be Used in All IVF?”

      1. Jessica says:

        Dear Dr. Sher,
        I very appreciate your expertise and advice. I live in australia and we have a 2 1/2 daughter conceived via icsi. We have subsequently tried to have a second but with no success after 3 stimulated cycles (gonalef -375-450 plus saizen). most recently, i ovulated on day 15 prior to egg collection. my dr has recommended if we try again that take a drug to suppress ovulation (orgalutran) twice daily instead of once. I am 37 and have dor, with typically 2-3 follicles per cyle and we are also dealing with male factor infertility. my husband (also 37) would have to undergo a biopsy to extract sperm. I know this is a difficult question, but I am not sure whether this sounds like such a complex case that we should give up after our 3 tries, or whether you think there is something else we should try? We would love to give our daughter a sibling but disagree whether this should be the end of the road. thanks very much in advance, Jessica from Sydney

        • Geoffrey Sher says:

          Hi Jessica,

          This sounds like a stimulation issue. What often can happen in women who have diminished ovarian reserve is premature luteinization (also referred to as a “premature LH surge”. It requires a revamp of the stimulation protocol and sometimes even that won’t work. Go elsewhere on this blog and read up on “prematrure luteinization”.

          Good luck!

          Geoff Sher

      2. yamzy says:

        Dear Dr Sher,
        Im from Sri Lanka age 33. I have undergone one IVF cycle with an antagonist protocol.I responded so well gonal-f225 and produced 18 eggs. Out of them 14 fertilized.07 fertilized on conventional ivf and two fertilised with icsi.but all fertilised through conventional ivf were highly fragmneted and the 2 icsi ones looked good and transfered. but sadly i didnt fall pregnant. im pcos and my husband who is 32 has low motility. Im thinking to try IVF. what advise you can give…? Is there any reason why those got highly fragmneted? my doctor said it could be sue to the protocol or the laboratory conditions or poor egg quality. but im confused and desperate. pls advise

        • Geoffrey Sher says:

          Hi Yamzy,

          My response to you would be the exact same as the response below to “Lisa’s” post. Please read that.

          Geoff Sher

      3. mahek says:

        we underwent 3 failed icsi cycles.
        first was due to absence of sperms in the biopsies (TESA-ICSI), second there were sperms present(surprisingly) in normal ejaculate(2 consecutive samples given after a gap of one hour)and the semen was cryopreserved, but i was having PCOS and excessive weight gain only made 4 eggs by stimulation, out of which only 2 were mature and only one fertilised and ofcourse i didnot concieve (also suffer hypothyroidism)
        third, i gave good response to stimulation and produced 11 eggs out of which 9 matured but unfortunately my husbands semen(both samples) no sperm found, and the cryopreserved sample was used out of 8 injected again only one divided(which i am not sure of good quality).
        The pregnancy test was obviously negative, what further proceudre can we do.My age is 30 and husband is 33.Thanks you

        • Geoffrey Sher says:

          There are several issues that need to be addressed. The first is the need for a very strategic and individualized protocol for ovarian stimulation (see below). The second is the accessing of sperm and the 3rd is the fact that most women who have hypothyroidism have an autoimmune cause which in 50% of cases is associated with an immunologic implantation dysfunction (see below).

          I really think we should talk and that I can help here. Please go to the home page of this blog, http://www.IVFauthority.com. When you get there, look for a “search bar” in the upper right hand corner. Type the following subjects into the bar, click on it and it will take you to all the relevant articles posted there.

          1. “An Individualized Approach to Ovarian stimulation” (posted on November 22nd, 2010)

          2. “Ovarian Stimulation in IVF: Why is it important to down-regulate LH?”

          3. “Thyroid autoimmune disease and IVF”

          4. “Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction” (posted on May, 10th and on May 16th respectively.

          5. “Embryo Implantation………” (Part-1 and Part- 2—-Posted August 2012)

          6. “Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)

          7.“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)

          8. “IVF success: Factors that influence outcome”

          9. “Staggered IVF”

          10.“Male Infertility”

          11. “Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)”

          12. “Hormonal treatment of male infertility”

          Consider calling 800-780-7437 or 702-699-7437 to arrange a Skype consultation (free of charge to those who reside in the United States or Canada) with me so we can discuss your case in detail

          Geoff Sher

      Leave a Reply

       

      RL, a 31-year-old woman, presented with a 7 year history of inability to conceive, in spite of 2 prior fresh and 1 frozen IVF ... Read more

      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...

      While many IVF pregnancies will progress normally and without any increased risk to mother or baby, there is little doubt ... Read more

      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...

      The following is a case study of a recent patient that came to me for treatment.  CJ, a 34 year old, and her husband RJ ... Read more

      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...

       Please refer to last week's blog post, where Karmann tells in her own words her struggles with recurrent miscarriage - nine ... Read more

      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the third and final post in three part series on embryo quality. In the prior two posts, I outlined the intrinsic/physiological factors and the clinical factors that can impact embryo “competence”.  In this post, I will discuss the rol... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      “At 45 years of age the incidence of aneuploidy is likely to be nine in ten.” Several weeks ago, I posted an article about endometrial receptivity and its effect on IVF success. This, as I noted, was the “Soil” component of the “See... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      I often refer to the conception process in terms of a “seed/soil” relationship.  Just as a plant can’t grow and thrive without first assuring that both seed and soil are good, neither can a pregnancy be successful without both the seed (e... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Acupuncture involves the insertion of thin needles into the skin along so-called meridians (energy channels). It has been used in China for centuries to regulate and treat many health disorders including ailments involving the female reproductive sys... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is #17 in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. For women whose advancing age and/or ovarian resistance make having a baby with their own eggs unfeasible or unlikely, IVF using donated eggs from a young donor (under 35 years)... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 15th in a series of responses to common questions about failed IVF There is little doubt that stress and emotional lability plays a role in the normal physiological/hormonal regulation of the menstrual cycle.After all, Eskimos often stopp... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      It is an unfortunate reality that many IVF programs attach little importance to factors that affect embryo implantation in general, and immunologic implantation dysfunction (IID) in specific (see below). Perhaps the lack of attention given to evaluat... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Procreation – and with it the ability to achieve immortality by living on through one’s children – is one of the most insatiable human needs. This strong natural urge exerts tremendous pressure on couples unable to have a baby. And ... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      It is not unusual for couples who share DQ alpha/HLA similarities to first give birth to a healthy baby only to subsequently develop infertility, recurrent IVF failure or recurrent pregnancy loss. Such couples find it hard to comprehend how after hav... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Dr. Geoffrey Sher Recommends

      Please join me on Wed, February 6 at 8:30pm Eastern for a live webinar where I’ll discuss this topic in detail and take your questions. For more information or to register, click HERE ————- I have, for many years, tak... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      IVF programs currently report their outcome statistics in a number of categories: a)      Number of IVF cycles initiated in a given year b)      Number of single and multiple pregnancies that occurred c)      Number of cycles that res... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      I wish to share a very interesting case with you; one that I’m pretty sure will meet with the approval of some and evoke criticism by others. Before I even tell you about it, let me say that I and my team thought long and hard before going ahead wi... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Couples have for centuries sought to influence the gender of their offspring. More than seven centuries ago the ancient Chinese developed a birth calendar said to be able to predict gender on the basis of when conception occurred. Later, the ancient ... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Acupuncture involves the insertion of thin needles into the skin along so-called meridians (energy channels). It has been used in China for centuries to regulate and treat many health disorders including ailments involving the female reproductive sys... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      ALLOIMMUNE VS. AUTOIMMUNE DYSFUNCTION Alloimmune Implantation Dysfunction Every human being has two DQ-alpha genes. One is contributed by the father and the other by the mother. In a small percentage of patients undergoing IVF, paternal-maternal DQ-a... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      It is an unfortunate reality that many IVF programs attach little importance to factors that affect embryo implantation in general, and immunologic implantation dysfunction (IID) in specific (see below). Perhaps the lack of attention given to evaluat... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      IVF patients, especially those who find themselves inexplicably repeatedly failing treatment after treatment are no longer willing to blindly accept platitudes from those who would ignore the role of immunologic causes of IVF failure while unable to ... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      For about 10% of all infertile couples, the cause of the infertility cannot be readily determined using conventional diagnostic methods. Such cases are often referred to as “unexplained infertility.” The truth, however, is that in most su... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      For more than a quarter century, medical scientists have attempted to defy the biological clock by freezing a woman’s eggs to preserve her fertility. Most of these efforts have failed. Consider the fact that since the birth of the world’s 1st “... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      RL, a 31-year-old woman, presented with a 7 year history of inability to conceive, in spite of 2 prior fresh and 1 frozen IVF attempts, where a total of six good quality blastocysts had been transferred to her uterus.  Her husband PL, had normal spe... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      The following is a case study of a recent patient that came to me for treatment.  CJ, a 34 year old, and her husband RJ (age 35) presented to me with a six-year history of infertility. Based on semen analysis, RJ, who had initiated two pregnancies i... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
       Please refer to last week’s blog post, where Karmann tells in her own words her struggles with recurrent miscarriage – nine miscarriages to be exact – and her long journey  of heartbreak, disappointment, and finally – hope.... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      In observation of National Infertility Awareness Week (NIAW), I wanted to share the touching story of a couple that I first met last year – after they had already experienced 8 years of heartbreak and frustration.  Their story is representativ... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Background: About two years ago, I received a call from a gentleman that I will call “John”. John was a movie producer who stated that he and his partner “Brian” had been in a monogamous same-sex relationship for 7 years and each wanted to si... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Background: Maria (fictitious name), a childless 34-year-old Hispanic lady, presented with a history of having had five (5) successive spontaneous pregnancy losses at 7 weeks gestation, all due to hydatidiform moles. Four (4) of these losses were ... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      Mary (fictitious name), a 54 year menopausal woman, presented at SIRM-Las Vegas for IVF using an egg donor. She had been menopausal for 7-plus years and had NOT been on any hormone replacement therapy. Mary gave a history of having undergone IVF with... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      I consulted with a 36 year old lady (whom I will refer to as “Sandra”) and her partner, about 18 months ago. She and her husband of 5 years had been having regular unprotected intercourse throughout this time and had been unable to conceive. Sand... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      About 18 months ago I saw an Asian Indian couple who presented with a very interesting history. The female partner (whom I will refer to as DB) had regular menstrual cycles and normal ovarian reserve, was ovulating regularly and had a fertile male pa... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the second in a series of posts taken from questions that have been submitted to me via email, website, or discussion boards.  This question is from a patient who had a healthy baby from her first pregnancy, but then went through a period of... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
       Please refer to last week’s blog post, where Karmann tells in her own words her struggles with recurrent miscarriage – nine miscarriages to be exact – and her long journey  of heartbreak, disappointment, and finally – hope.... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the second part of a two-part post on IVF failure. In my January 22nd post, I discussed what I often refer to as the “seed” variable in the “seed/soil” relationship – the embryo. This week’s post will address the “soil” variab... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 19th in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. Early pregnancy loss – whether due to miscarriage or chemical pregnancy – is due to two major factors. In more than 70-80% of cases the cause is attributable to... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is no. 18 in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. While it is true that IVF failure can be due to preventable factors, it is as important to understand that optimal medical care does not always equate with an optimal outcome... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is #17 in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. For women whose advancing age and/or ovarian resistance make having a baby with their own eggs unfeasible or unlikely, IVF using donated eggs from a young donor (under 35 years)... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 16th in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. Immediately following implantation, the root system (trophoblast) of the embryo begins to release the pregnancyhormone, human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) into the surround... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 15th in a series of responses to common questions about failed IVF There is little doubt that stress and emotional lability plays a role in the normal physiological/hormonal regulation of the menstrual cycle.After all, Eskimos often stopp... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 14th in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. In vitro fertilization establishes an abnormal hormonal environment in the uterus.In some cases (especially older women and those with a diminished ovarian reserve), high o... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 13th in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. Virtually everyone recognizes that pregnancy with multiples (especially triplets or greater) is associated with a high incidence of premature delivery that has serious cons... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...
      This is the 12th in a series of answers to common questions about failed IVF. (Note: I’ll be hosting a live video chat on Aug. 2 on the topic of Failed IVF where I’ll discuss the issues addressed in this series of posts and take your ques... more
      1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
      Loading ... Loading ...

      Ask Dr. Geoffrey Sher

      PST: Pacific Standard Time
      CAPTCHA Image

      Enter Code*:
      Reload Image
      Business Hours
      Mon - Fri ( 9a - 5p ) PST
      CALL US TOLL FREE : (866)428-3222
      Ask Our Doctors
      A Question