Case Study: “Unexplained” Repeated Failed IVF in a Young Woman With Normal Ovarian Reserve: Case #4
702-892-9696
Fax:
702-892-9666
Today we continue our series of case studies on unexplained IVF failure with our fourth case of poor egg/embryo quality in young women. In this case study, we examine the effects of a combination of endometriosis and Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction.
Background
“Jamie” consulted with me when she was 34 years of age, after 3 years of failed treatment and a diagnosis of “unexplained infertility.”A laparoscopy had revealed her to have mild (Stage 1) endometriosis which was ablated at the time of surgery.The patient had undergone 3 IUI procedures, using clomiphene citrate in the first two procedures and letrazole in the last one.In all cases she developed between 5-8 follicles and triggered with 10,000 units of hCG.Ovulation occurred uniformly throughout, but she failed to conceive.
She then moved on to In Vitro Fertilization, and over the course of 18 months, she underwent 3 failed IVF attempts.In each case she was stimulated with a modest, long pituitary down-regulation protocol involving the use of birth control pills, overlapped with an agonist (Lupron).Upon the onset of menstruation, she received between 250-400 units of gonadotropins (Gonal F/Menopur) daily for between 8 and 10 days.Her peak estradiol levels ranged between 2000-2600 pg/ml on the day of the hCG trigger (10,000 units of Novarel), at which point she had an excellent endometrium by ultrasound examination, (trilaminar and more than 9mm in thickness).Between 12 and 16 oocytes were recovered at egg retrieval, and following ICSI, she consistently produced between 2 and 5 blastocysts. Embryo transfers involving 2-3 blastocysts failed to achieve a pregnancy.At the time of our consultation she had 4 cryobanked (vitrified) blastocysts that not been transferred.
Follow Up: We performed immunologic testing on this patient and found her to have activated Natural Killer cells (NKa) by the K562 target cell test, as well as antiphospholipid antibodies (APA).We made a diagnosis of autoimmune implantation dysfunction and scheduled the patient for a frozen embryo transfer (FET) with her residual cryobanked blastocysts.We prepared her with twice-weekly injections of Delestrogen (6 mg) combined with 0.75 mg dexamethasone daily, and 30 mg Lovenox daily starting at the onset of her cycle.
Approximately 10 days prior to the anticipated FET she received an Intralipid (IL) infusion.At ET, we transferred 3 thawed blastocysts.Eight days later, her first beta hCG was 45, and 2 days afterward it had risen to 160.She thereupon received a second and final intralipid infusion. A subsequent ultrasound examination 3 weeks later revealed a healthy set of twins.She was weaned off the dexamethasone at 10 weeks gestation.The patient is presently about 24 weeks pregnant and progressing normally.
Commentary:This patient’s infertility was really not “unexplainable” it was simply undiagnosed.Clearly there was not an underlying egg/embryo issue at all.The reason she failed to conceive on her own (in spite of spontaneous and regular ovulation) and following IUI was almost certainly due to the fact that all women with endometriosis (regardless of severity) have an underlying toxic peritoneal factor that compromises fertilization as the eggs pass from the ovary(ies) to the sperm waiting in the fallopian tube(s).This reduces fertilization potential and therefore compromises fecundity.This toxic peritoneal factor is present in 100% of women with this condition and explains why the chance of having a baby is reduced 4-6 fold in women with even the mildest of endometriosis.Since the visual endometriotic deposits represent just a small percentage of those that are in the process of developing, neither surgery to remove such lesions nor fertility drugs with or without IUI will likely significantly improve the baby rate per cycle (fecundity).
Furthermore, there was the issue of an immunologic implantation dysfunction (IID) as evidenced by NK cell activation and antiphospholipid antibodies.IID occurs in about 30% of women who have endometriosis, and when it is associated with NK cell activation, the chance of a successful pregnancy is very low.When we administered intralipid, heparin (Lovenox) and steroids (dexamethasone), down-regulated the activated uterine NK cells, and counteracted the influence of antiphospholipid antibodies, the patient readily conceived following FET.
The lesson in this case is that all women with endometriosis have diminished fecundity because of the consistent presence of a toxic pelvic environment that cannot be resolved through surgery or medical manipulation.Only IVF, by transferring the embryo directly to the uterus, can bypass this problem.
I do not mean to imply that all women with endometriosis will require IVF.In fact, for younger women who have associated ovulation dysfunction (which is not uncommon in women with endometriosis), fertility drugs can be tried.However, this will only deal with the ovulation dysfunction, but will not address the toxic peritoneal factor.Simply stated, women with mild to moderate endometriosis that conceive following the use of fertility drugs (with or without IUI), usually achieve this in spite of, rather than due to, such treatment.Ultimately, only IVF which consistently bypasses the toxic pelvic environment, will address this problem.
Since 1/3 of women with endometriosis will have an IID which will prevent implantation, even IVF will fail unless this problem is dealt with through down-regulation of NK cell activity and treatment of often associated anti-phospholipid antibodies (as was done in this case).
In summary, normally ovulating women with endometriosis-associated infertility who are under the age of 35 years, should consider timed intercourse (using home ovulation testing).If this fails to result in a pregnancy, IVF will in all likelihood be required.For women who do not ovulate normally, fertility drugs can be used to correct this problem, but when such treatment is implemented, it must be done with the full understanding that ovulation induction will not reverse the toxic peritoneal effect.Ultimately, IVF might still be needed.
For women over the age of 35 and those with diminished ovarian reserve (cases where time is of the essence), IVF treatment should, in my opinion, be the first line of attack.
Addendum: It is important to understand that IVF is an ART-Science blend and not all practitioners agree on the same strategies. Thus, in the final analysis, it is important, after discussion with your personal doctor, to follow his/her advice to the letter.
Feel free to present your case history in the comments and I will do my best to offer my opinion.
24 Responses to “Case Study: “Unexplained” Repeated Failed IVF in a Young Woman With Normal Ovarian Reserve: Case #4”
Leave a Reply
Top Search Terms for In Vitro Fertilization
- Embryo Quality & Embryo “Competence” – Part III – Testing the Seed
- Embryo Quality & Embryo “Competence” – Part One: Planting a Good Seed
- The Needle vs. the Dish: Should ICSI Be Used in All IVF?
- Embryo Implantation: What Farmers Can Teach us About Growing Healthy Babies
- Acupuncture and IVF: Does it Improve Success?
Ask Our DoctorsA Question














Hi,
I am 31 yrs old and TTc from past 4 yrs, 3 yrs with IVF.
I have had 4 failed IVFs due to implantation failure. I had endometrioma which was removed 4 yrs back. Tubal blockage at Perifimbrial end.
In 4th IVF I tried IVIG and heparin.
Embryo quality was good in all cycles and 4-5 embies were transferred.
Can tubal blockage cause toxic fluid which might be killing the embryos.
I had unusual spotting while on last phase of ovarian stimulation.
Can be it related to tubal discharge(hematosalpinx)?
I once conceived naturally between the ivf cycles but miscarried at 2 months.
Thanks for your help doctor.
Unless the tube(s) is/are distended with fluid (visible on ultrasound), it is not likely to be due to reflux of toxic fluid into the uterus.
At 31, you should be able to conceive and have a baby with IVF. The fact that you were on IVIG once, is significant but not definitive. That cycle could have been one where the embryo(s) was/were chromosomally defective or the timing and dosage of IVIG might not have been right. It is also possible that, rather than an autoimmune implantation dysfunction, yours is alloimmune and if so the treatment needs to be modified.
Please go to http://www.IVFauthority.com and when you get to the home page find the “search bar” in the right hand column. Type in the following subjects into the bar and it will take you to all the relevant articles I posted there.
“An Individualized Approach to Ovarian stimulation” (posted on November 22nd, 2010)
“Agonist/Antagonist Conversion Protocol”
“Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction” (posted on May, 10th and on May 16th respectively.
“IVF success: Factors that influence outcome”
“Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)
“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)
“Staggered IVF”
I think I can help you sort this out, so consider calling 800-780-7437 or 702-699-7437 to set up a web-based video conference or a telephone consultation with me (which is free if you reside in the U.S.A or in Canada) so we might discuss your case in detail.
Geoff Sher
Thnx doc for ur invaluable response.
IVIG was given during start of ovarian stimulation..
Embryo transfer was done 1 month after the IVIG drip, As fresh cycle was converted to a FET due to unusual bleeding.
BTW my TNF alpha test was normal. can there still be any immune problem?
Thnx Doc.
The uterine cytokine test is helpful but not conclusive. You need a K562 target cell test for NK cell activity . This must be done in an Reproductive Immunology Refe4rrence Lab such as Reprosource (in Boston) or Reproductive Immunology Associates (in Van Nuys, CA). Call them and have your blood sent there for this test.
Good luck!
Geoff Sher
Hi Dr. Sher,
I am 31 years old and have done 4 IUIs and 9 IVF transfers (3 of which were FETs) over the last 3 years. I have only gotten pregnant on 2 of these, both which were chemical pregnancies. The last 2 transfers I had were from donor embryos. I am going to be doing another cycle next month and hope to transfer 2 more donor embryos as blasts if they make it from the thaw to that stage. What are my chances of success after so many failed attempts? I have “unexplained” infertility and am on Lovenox to help my chances out since I have high beta 2 glycoprotein levels. I have been to 2 clinics, so I am doubtful that there is anything that they missed. What are your thoughts? Thanks in advance for any help you may have.
Hi lauren,
I empathize but you need to appreciate that with repeated embryos transferred where these were derived from the eggs of a young woman and you repeatedly fail to conceive, this makes the most likely explanation an implantation problem. If that is the case, whether you use own eggs or donor eggs wont matter until this is addressed,. The implantation problem could be anatomical (lining thickness and/or surface lesions such as polyps in the uterine cavity) or an immunologic implantation dysfunction. My bet is on the latter. You have not provided enough information to help me understand as to why an egg donor was needed in your case.
Please go to http://www.IVFauthority.com and when you get to the home page find the “search bar” in the right hand column. Type in the following subjects into the bar and it will take you to all the relevant articles I posted there.
“Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction” (posted on May, 10th and on May 16th respectively.
“Embryo Implantation………” (Part-1 and Part- 2—-Posted August 2012)
“Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)
“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)
“IVF success: Factors that influence outcome”
“Embryo Banking”
“Egg Donation”
Consider calling 800-780-7437 or 702-699-7437 to arrange a telephone or Skype consultation (free of charge to those who reside in the United States or Canada). While an audiovisual (Skype) interaction is much more personable and preferable than a discussion by telephone, either will suffice.
Geoff Sher
I am now more persuaded than ever that your problem is likely hitherto undiagnosed implantation dysfunction. Please understand that doing immunologic testing does not mean that the right tests were done. You probably need a K-562 target cell test for natural killer cell activation, a full antiphospholipid antibody profile, an immunophenotype, antithyroglobulin and antimicrosomal antibodies plus, you and you husband need to be matched for DQ alpha and HLA similarities. In my opinion there are only 2-4 Reproductive Immunology Reference Laboratories in the United Stares that can perform these tests adequately. My preference would be to contact Reproductive Immunology Associates in Van Nuys, CA or \Reprosource in Boston, MA.
I think I can help here so call 800-780-7437 or 702-281-7437 and set up a medical consultation with me by Skype or Telephone.
Geoff Sher
I thought I should mention also that I have had several sonohystograms, a hysterosalpingogram both of which did not give the physicians any concern, and went to a hematologist who prescribed me the Lovenox, as I believe the only finding he could see was my elevated beta 2 glycoprotein levels. During my transfers, I had several protocols which used Follistim, Ganerelix, Lupron, Menopur, and I believe one other medicine. What additional testing would you recommend? I decided to use donor embryos after having several cycles where I did not have many embryos to retrieve (one cycle I did not have anything to transfer, another I had 3 4A embryos transferred, and then moved on with donor sperm, which did produce healthier looking embryos, but still only 3-4 which would go to 6 or 8 cell. The only two cycles which initially took were both blasts (one which was mine, and the other which was the donor embryo), none of the 8 or less cell transfers took. Would you suggest any additional testing? Do you think there could be something they missed? Do you have any thoughts as to why I would not be successful with donor embryos (the embryos actually had donor egg too, and the couple before me had instant success). Do you think you may be able to help me succeed?
Dear Dr. Sher, I tried to set up a consultation, but since I have already started medications, they could not assist me. THey suggested I contact you once I have completed this cycle. So,I will contact you once the cycle is completed unless you want to speak before then. Thank you for your assistance and some shred of hope.
Lauren
I suggest you set up the consultation now (tell them I so advised). If you conceive and do not need me thereafter, call up 800-780-7437 and cancel.
Good luck!
Geoff Sher
had 1 failed ivf and 1 failed FET so far. I’m 33 and my husband 38. My dr says I have no problem whatsoever. My husband suffers from OCD and hence take medications to help alleviate his anxiety: rivotril, Effexor and seroquel. Although he had previously done a sperm test that came back normal my dr seems to think that my embryos are not implanting because of these medications that might affect the sperm in some way. By the way with both our cycles we had PGD done for all our embryos so its not because of chromosomal abnormality that they are not implanting. Your help will be highly appreciated. I’m starting to loose hope.
Responded to both posts above!
I also want to add that I had an HSG test done plus a pelvic MRI and it all came back normal. My uterine lining is always perfect (above 9mm). But for some reasons my embryos won’t implant. Could it be the medications that my husband uses?
You need a full immunologic implantation assessment.This is not likely to be attributable to meds your husband is using. Please go to http://www.IVFauthority.com and when you get to the home page find the “search bar” in the right hand column. Type in the following subjects into the bar and it will take you to all the relevant articles I posted there.
“Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction” (posted on May, 10th and on May 16th respectively.
“Embryo Implantation………” (Part-1 and Part- 2—-Posted August 2012)
“Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)
“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)
“IVF success: Factors that influence outcome”
Geoff Sher
Dr. Sher,
I have stage 4 endometriosis. My husband and I are weeks away from starting our first attempt at IVF. I am to say the least a bit nervous and hope that because of the cost and stress. Since the IVF is near, I have been wondering if there are steps that I can take to increase my chances of success. I was on Clomid for the max amount of time, about 5-6 months, max dose 50 mg. I believe that from so much stimulation from the Clomid that it caused me to have endometriosis. My Doctor at Shady Grove insisted that this isnt true. On my own, I read many posts from other women who took Clomid who experienced similar symptoms. I have had two lap surgeries to remove the endometriosis and unfortunately both fallopian tubes. IVF is our only option. After reading many posts on your site I am interested in getting tested for immunologic factors including Antiphospholipid Antibodies (APA) and Natural Killer cell activation (NKa). The first step in my IVF cycle is bloodwork & ultrasound. I was wondering if I should also get an HSG to check to see how my ovaries and uterus look. I am trying to be proactive. Do you think that this is the right approach and would you suggest that I do anything else to increase my chances. Concerned because my endoetriosis is stage 4 and I have already experienced so much heartbreak from having tubes removed and pain associated with endo. I was also thinking of checking in my area to see if I should consider the Sclerotherapy as well. Thank you kindly for your assistance and very informative site.
There are c2 considerations. The 1st is to exclude an ovarian endometrioma and to defer IVF until that has been eliminated. If you do not do this then the eggs that are harvested from the affected ovary are likely to be of poor quality. The second is to exclude autoimmune implantation dysfunction that occurs in 30% of endometriosis cases , regardless of severity. However with regard to this issue, I suspect that you will meet with resistance by your RE . When you are told (as I expect will happen) that he/she does not believe in immunologic factors impacting implantation, remember to demand a cleat explanation of the scientific theory that the doctor does not agree with and for reasons why. In most cases you will find such explanation to be lacking because many RE’s do not understand the principles of immunologic implantation(see the articles on Endometriosis and the ones on immunologic implantation dysfunction, elsewhere on http://www.IVFauthority.com).
Good luck!
Geoff Sher
HI Dr Sher
Is it a case of immunologic implantation dysfunction if IVF failed although the NK cell K562 test was normal and intralipid was administered? Is there a need to do further testing of APA in this case to diagnose deeper issues or could the failed IVF be something else?
Thanks,
If interpretation of NKa (correctly performed) was accurately found to be normal, then you can by and large rule out an autoimmune implantation dysfunction.
Geoff Sher
Dr. Sher,
I have endometreosis and to date have two failed IVF cycles and two failed FETs. My immunologic testing (performed at Reprosource) revealed activated NKc and extremely high cytokine levels. I was treated with lovenox, intralips, and a high dose of prednisone in conjunction with my second IVF cycle. My cytokine and NKc barely responded, and the IVF cycle was unsuccessful. Thoughts?
Megan
Remember, simply correcting the endometrial receptivity alone, does not impact embryo quality.
Please go to the home page of this blog, (www.IVFauthority.com). When you get there look for a “search bar” in the upper right hand column. Then type in the following subjects into the bar, click and this will take you to all the relevant articles I posted there.
1. “An Individualized Approach to Ovarian stimulation” (posted on November 22nd, 2010)
2. “Ovarian Stimulation in IVF: Why is it important to down-regulate LH?”
3. “Agonist/Antagonist Conversion Protocol”
4. “Immunologic Implantation Dysfunction” (posted on May, 10th and on May 16th respectively.
5. “Embryo Implantation………” (Part-1 and Part- 2—-Posted August 2012)
6. “Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)
7.“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)
8. “IVF success: Factors that influence outcome”
9. Endometriosis”
Consider calling 800-780-7437 or 702-699-7437 to arrange a telephone or Skype consultation (free of charge to those who reside in the United States or Canada) with me so we can discuss your case in detail.
Geoff Sher
Hi,
In the past 1 1/2 yrs. I have had 4 IVF cycles and 1 FET. None of which have worked. I had 1 chemical pregnancy. I have a problem of which I don’t get my period and my uterus gets thick and I have had 2 biopsies cause of this. My 1st biopsy came back with simple & comlex hyperplasya without atypia. The second one came back normal. I had 2 surgies to clean out my uterus(I have PCOS too). Of all my IVF’S the last one I had 5 day blast that made it freeze. They told my I have egg quality issues. My last IVF cycle I had 5-8 grade cells that they said looked great and 1-4 cell that they said was pretty good too. My insurance covered 4 IVF cycles(otherwise I coud not afford to do this). After my last IVF failed then my doctor did a US HSG, which came back that I need my second surgery to remove polys. By this time I only had my 2 frozen left. Why wouldn’t they have checked this prior to my last IVF? I had a regular HSG about 2-3 years ago. I’m so desperate and upset. What should be my next step. PLEASE HELP! I probably should have mentioned that I am 36yrs old and been TTC for many years.
I sense your desperation and would be happy to review your records thoroughly and advise. To do that you would need to call 702-699-7437 and set up a Skype consultation with me.
Good luck!
Geoff Sher
I have been married since 6 years . Initially I went 6 iui all unsuccessful . Then we went to another doctor who suggested laparoscopy. I had adhesions septum uterus and my tbpcr was positive the I underwent anti tb treatment for 7 months and had three unsuccessful iui after which I underwent Ivf it was successful and had fetal heartbeat on 6 week of pregnancy I had mild bleeding and on 8 week ultrasound the heartbeat was not there . I had d /e procedure and again went 2 more ivf 1 frozen and another fresh both failed then I came to usa . All my test and my husband test is normal my biopsy for tbpcr is also negative. So we went ahead with stimulation retrieved 9 eggs three fertilized but on the day of retrieval my uterus showed water accumulation so we underwent next artificial cycle I was on estrogen patch vaginal cream and oral tablet for almost 26 days and my lining was 6.8 before progesterone start but again this failed so please guide me how to proceed further I have one frozen embryo
It sounds as if the intrauterine infection might have severely damaged your potential to develop a good uterine lining. This is the likely reason for the miscarriage as well as the thin lining in your last cycle. Sometimes the lining can be enhanced with estrogen therapy and vaginal viagra.
I would be happy to discuss this with you. Consider calling 800-780-7437 or 702-699-7437 to arrange a Skype consultation (free of charge to those who reside in the United States or Canada) with me so we can discuss your case in detail
Please go to the home page of this blog, http://www.IVFauthority.com . When you get there, look for a “search bar” in the upper right hand corner. Type the following subjects into the bar, click on it and it will take you to all the relevant articles posted there.
1. “Pelvic Tuberculosis and IVF”
2. “Asherman’s syndrome”
3. “Endometrial thickness and Viagra therapy”
4. “Embryo Implantation………” (Part-1 and Part- 2—-Posted August 2012)
5. “Traveling for IVF from Out of State/Country– The Process at SIRM-Las Vegas” (posted on March, 21st 2012)
7.“A personalized, stepwise approach to IVF at SIRM”; Parts 1 & 2 (posted March, 2012)
8. “Gestational Surrogacy”
Geoff Sher